The Boscombe Valley Mystery.
Arthur Conan Doyle
Leader : Joy - John Turner, Moran
Members : QiaoHui – Mrs. Moran, Mrs. Watson
Sze Kei – Charles McCarthy
Alia – Inspector Lestrade, Judge
Qistina – Patience Moran, Alice Turner
Sharmic – Sherlock Holmes, Policeman
Kesh – James McCarthy, Watson
Chapter 1
At Dr Watson’s house. Watson received a telegram from Sherlock Holmes.
Watson : “Are you free for a few days? I’m going to the west of England. Murder at Boscombe Valley. Come with me. Leave Paddington on the 11.15 train. Holmes.”
Half an hour later at Paddinton Station, Watson met Holmes.
Later in the train, they talk about the murder.
Holmes ; “ Do you know anything about this case, Watson? ”
Watson; “ No, Holmes. Is it murder? ”
Holmes ; “ It seems so. The murdered man’s unfortunate son is in prison now. He’s the main suspect. ”
Watson ; “ But you don’t think he’s guilty, Holmes? ”
Holmes ; “ No, I don’t. A simple case can be very complex in reality, my dear Watson.”
Holmes begins to tell Watson about the case.
Holmes ; “ The McCarthy family lives on the estate of a rich gentlemen, Mr John Turner. In Boscombe Valley near Ross-On-Wye.”
Watson : “ Where does Mr Turner’s money come from?”
Holmes ; “ That is rather a mystery, Watson. He is not from Ross-On-Wye, he came to England from Australia about twenty years ago. No-one knows anything about him.”
Watson ; “ Were Charles McCarthy and Turner friends?”
Holmes ; “ I think so. McCarthy was also in Australia for many years.”
Watson ; “ Has Mr Turner has any children?”
Holmes ; “ Yes, he has got one daughter. Her name’s Alice. She’s eighteen, like James McCarthy. Mrs Turner is dead.”
Chapter 2
Watson ; “ What do the newspaper say about the case, Holmes?”
Holmes ; “ “The Star” says that, on Monday, Charles McCarthy left his house at 3 o’clock and walked to Boscombe Pool, a small lake near his farm.
Watson ; “ I see, and then?”
Holmes ; “ The police arrest his son for murder the next day. Here Watson – you read it. “
James McCarthy arrived home from Bristol on Monday morning and went straight to his room. He was in his room when his father arrived. Mr McCarthy told the servant, ‘ I’m late. I have an appointment at 3 o’clock. I must leave immediately. ‘
His son didn’t see him go out. James took his gun and walked to Boscombe Pool to shoot rabbits.
Holmes ; “ There are two witnesses. One is the gamekeeper. “
Watson ; “ What does he say? “
Holmes ; “ He says he saw Charles McCarthy in the wood and then he met James McCarthy a few minutes later with a gun. Both men were on the path for Boscombe Pool. The second witness is a young girl of 14, the gamekeeper’s daughter, Patience Moran. “
Watson ; “ A child? Is she important? “
Holmes ; “ Yes, she is. She saw McCarthy and his son having an argument at the pool. She saw James raise his hand, perhaps to hit his father. She was afraid and ran home to tell her mother. “
Chapter 3
Watson ; “ What does McCarthy’s son say about the murder and about the gun? What about the argument with his father? “
Holmes ; “ He says he doesn’t know anything and the gun was only for shooting rabbits. “
Patience Moran’s home, the day of the murder.
Patience ; “ Mother! Mother! “
Mrs. Moran ; “ Patience! What’s the matter, child? “
Patience ; “ Master James is arguing terribly with his father! They’re up at Boscombe Pool! “
A few minutes later, James run to Moran’s house and asks for help.
Near the pool, Moran, the gamekeeper and a policeman find Charles McCarthy’s body.
Policeman ; “ This is a terrible murder. Look at his head. “
Moran ; “ Yes. The murderer hit him violently four or five times. “
Policeman ; “ Yes. He hit him with something heavy – a gun? “
Moran ; “ But where’s the weapon? “
Policeman ; “ I don’t know. Let’s look for it. “
Chapter 4
A few minutes later, Moran found the weapon.
Moran ; “ Oh dear God! It’s James McCarthy’s gun! “
James was arrested then.
In Ross-On-Wye people are talking about the murder. Some of them thinks James is guilty but some don’t.
Watson ; “ I see. Very interesting, but this case is closed; McCarthy is guilty. “
Holmes ; “ Why do you say that? “
Watson ; “ There are two witnesses and his gun. It’s clear the son killed the father. “
Holmes ; “ On the contrary, my dear Watson, the case is not clear. Someone thinks James is totally innocent. Miss Alice Turner. And here is Alice Turner’s telegram to me. “
Mr Sherlock Holmes esq.
22, Baker Street
LONDON.
Chapter 5
Holmes ; “ And that, Watson, is why we are here. Miss Turner wants our help. The police think McCarthy’s guilty but Alice Turner thinks he is innocent. “
Watson ; “ I see. But the evidence seems to show McCarthy is guilty. “
Holmes ; “ Think again, Watson. The arrest was not immediate – there was time for the murderer to escape. And, remember the boy’s strange words at his arrest.” At his trial, James McCarthy told the court about that fateful day… “
James says Charles was out for an appointment that day , while he goes hunting in the woods and met Moran
Chapter 6
At Boscombe Pool, James hears a familiar sound.
Charles ; “ Coeee ! “
James ; “ Coeee! “
Charles ; “ James! What are you doing here? “
James ; “ Why are you surprised? Coeee is our usual call. “
Charles ; “ Ummm… oh yes, yes. Listen son, I want to speak to you. “
James ; “ No father, I know what you want, but I can’t do it! “
Charles ; “ I am your father, you must do what I say! “
James ; “ No, father. It’s impossible! No! No! “
Charles ; “ AAAHHH!!! “
James ; “ Father, father! What’s the matter? What’s wrong? Father, who was it ? Who hurt you? “
Charles ; “ Raaat… “
Back in the court room.
Judge ; “ Can you tell us about the argument? “
James ; “ No, I’m sorry I can’t – it’s private. “
Judge ; “ Can you remember anything more about the place? “
James ; “ Yes. I remember something on the ground, something grey. A coat, I think.
Chapter 7
Holmes and Watson go to visit Alice Turner At a local hotel.
Alice ; “ Mr Holmes! I’m so happy to meet you. James is innocent. He is too kind to hurt anyone. “
Holmes ; “ And the argument with his father? Do you know anything about that? “
Alice ; “ Yes, the argument was about me. Mr McCarthy wanted James to marry me. “
Holmes ; “ And do you want to marry James? “
Alice ; “ I … I … James doesn’t want to marry. He’s too young. “
Watson ; “ Is your father in favour of the marriage? “
Alice ; “ No, not at all. He doesn’t want us to marry. “
Holmes ; “ I see. Could I talk to your father, Miss Turner? Perhaps tomorrow? Or next week? “
Alice ; “ No, I’m sorry. He’s too ill to see anyone. “
Watson ; “ What’s the matter with him my dear? “
Alice ; “ The doctor says his heart is very weak. He became ill after the murder. Now he has to stay in bed all the time. I’m sorry I must go now. My father is very bad today – he needs me. Goodbye Mr Holmes. “
Chapter 8
After visiting Alice, Holmes went to the Ross-On-Wye prison to look about James.
Holmes ; “ Tell me about the murder, my boy. “
James ; “ I don’t know anything about it. “
Holmes ; “ What do you mean? “
James ; “ It’s true I had an argument with my father at Boscombe Pool, but I didn’t murder him. I’m innocent, Mr Holmes. “
Holmes ; “ Don’t worry, my boy. I’m going to help you. I already have some ideas about the identity of the murderer. “
James ; “ Please hurry, Mr Holmes. I can’t stand this awful place. “
Back at the hotel, Holmes told Watson about what James said in the prison.
Holmes ; “ He’s young and handsome with a good heart, but he’s not very clever.”
Watson ; “ James has good friends, Miss Turner believes he is innocent. “
Holmes ; “ Ah yes. Miss Turner. I’m afraid there is an unhappy story there, Watson . “
Watson ; “ Really?? “
Holmes ; “James McCarthy does want to marry Alice Turner, he loves her very much. But he’s already married. “
Watson ; “ Already married!! Good God!! “
Holmes ; “ Exactly, Watson. But maybe something good can come from all this mess. “
Watson ; “ How, Holmes? “
Chapter 9
Holmes ; “ James McCarthy married a barmaid in Bristol 2 years ago in secret. It was not a happy union and they live apart. That is the reason he told his father he couldn’t marry Alice Turner. “
Watson ; “ It seems a hopeless situation. “
Holmes ; “ Not quite, Watson. Today I heard some good news. McCarthy’s wife read about the murder in the newspapers. Now she thinks her husband James McCarthy is a murderer. She wants a divorce. She wants to marry another man.”
Watson ; “ Then McCarthy is free! He can marry Alice! “
Holmes ; “ I hope so, Watson. “
Watson ; “ But about the case, Holmes? Any new developments? “
Holmes ; “ Well, for me there are 2 important points. One, Charles McCarthy knows his murderer and arranges to meet him at Boscombe Pool. “
Watson ; “ And the second point? “
Holmes ; “ That McCarthy cries ‘ Coeee ! ‘ “
Watson ; “ But that’s clear. He’s calling his son. It’s their special call. “
Holmes ; “ No, Watson. He doesn’t know his son is there. He;s using that particular cry to call someone else. But who? “
The next day Holmes and Watson meet Lestrade at Boscombe Pool to search for clues.
Lestrade ; “ There’s some bad news, I’m afraid. Mr Turner is very ill. The doctor thinks he’s going to die. “
Watson ; “ What’s the matter with him? “
Lestrade : “ His daughter says he’s ill because of the shock of the murder. “
Holmes ; “ Look here, Watson! These must be James McCarthy;s foorprints and those are the gamekeeper, Moran’s.
Watson ; “These other foorprints are very unusual. They have square toes. What kind of boots are they? “
Holmes ; “ We have a lot of important clues here, Watson. We are near the solution of this case. Please leave me alone for a few minutes. I must concentrate… “
Chapter 10
Holmes ; “ Inspector Lestrade, here is the murder weapon ! “
Lestrade ; “ Good heavens! But how do you know it’s the murder weapon? “
Holmes ; “ Because the instrument used to kill McCarthy made unusual marks on his head. Marks from something heavy and sharp. And this stone still has blood on it. Look. I can also tell you what our murderer looks like. He’s a tall man. He is left-handed and limps on his right leg. He wears heavy work boots and a grey coat. He smokes Indian cigars. “
Lestrade ; “ But I can’t arrest every man who smokes cigars and limps. Everyone in Scotland Yard Is going to laugh at me! “
Holmes ; “ I’m sorry, that’s all I can tell you, Inspector. You must do the rest yourself. Watson, you and I are returning to London tonight. The case is solved.”
Back at the hotel
Watson ; “ How do you know who the murderer is, Holmes? “
Holmes ; “ Elementary. My dear Watson. There are lots of clues. One, Charles McCarthy cries ‘ Coeee! ‘ and two, his last words are ‘ Raaat ‘. ‘ Coeee ‘ is an Australian word, only Australians use it. So we know that McCarthy called to someone who recognized the cry, someone from Australia . now, look at this, Watson. This is a map of the state of Victoria in Australia. What does it say here?”
Watson ; “ R-A-T… rat. Oh, I see~! It’s the end of a place name – Ballarat!! “
Holmes ; “ Exactly, McCarthy tried to say “ Ballarat “ to his son before he died. And remember, McCarthy lived in Ballarat for many years. “
Watson ; “ What about the other details? His height, his boots, the cigars? “
Holmes ; “ I can deduce his height and the fact that he limps from his footsteps in the mud near Boscombe Pool. “
Watson ; “ Of course! And the type of the boots he wears ! “
Holmes ; “ Right again, Watson ! heavy, square-toed boots, the type of boots they wear in the Australian bush ! “
Watson ; “ But how do you know he is left-handed? “
Holmes ; “ Because the murderer hit the victim on the left side of his head. That’s unusual. “
Watson ; “ And the cigars? “
Holmes ; “ There was ash from a cigar behind that tree near the pool. The murderer waited for McCarthy there. It’s an expensive Indian cigar. Only one man in the area is rich enough to smoke those cigars. “
Watson ; “ Of course! Now I know the man you’re thinking of… “
Chapter 11
Three days later at Holmes’ house in Baker Street. Turner came to visit Holmes and Watson.
Watson ; “ Please sit down, Mr Turner. You have Holme’s letter I see. “
Turner ; “ Yes. It says you want to see me, that you don’t want a scandal, I don’t understand. “
Holmes ; “ Oh I think you do. You see, I know everything about Charles McCarthy’s murder. “

Turner ; “ Then God help me ! I don’t want James McCarthy to hang, I promise you, Mr Holmes. But I don’t want to hurt my daughter. She loves me so much! “
Holmes ; “ I know. But perhaps It isn’t necessary to tell her. Remember I’m not a police officer. You can talk to me in confidence, Mr Turner.
Turner ; “ But I want to die in my own house, not in prison. “
Holmes ; “ I understand. We need to know the truth to save James, but we can keep the information private at present. You must write a confession and leave it in my hands until… “
Turner ; “ You mean until my death, when you can tell the police the truth? “
Holmes ; “ Yes. Then your confession can save James McCarthy’s life. “
Turner ; “ Alright. But please, Mr Holmes, don’t tell my daughter Alice. In reality Charles McCarthy and I were enemies. He was an evil man… I met him in Australia. I was very poor then. I did many things I’m ashamed of now… No-one called me John Turner. I had a different name… “
1860s near Ballarat, Australia. There was a stagecoach going from Ballarat to Melbourne.
Turner ; “. I put a gun to the head of the stagecoach driver. That man was Charles McCarthy. “
Turner ; “ Give me the gold! Now!! “
Charles ; “ Oh my god! It’s Black Jack of Ballarat! Yes, yes, take the gold! Take everything! Only please don’t shoot me! “
Turner ; “ I’m not going to shoot you! I don’t want to waste a bullet on a coward! “
Turner ; “ After the robbery my troubles were over. I was rich ! I left Australia as soon as possible and came to England to live. Here no-one knew my terrible secret. “
Chapter 12
Twenty years later in Regent Street, London.
Charles ; “ Turner! John Turner! Do you remember me? “
Turner ; “ No, I’m sorry, there must be some mistake… “
Charles ; “ Perhaps if I call you Black Jack of Ballarat, you might remember me? “
Turner ; “ No! Dear God, no! what are you doing here McCarthy? What do you want?? “
Charles ; “ I need a place to live. I want you to give me a house. I want money.”
Turner ; “ I’m not going to give you anything! “
Charles ; “ Please yourself. But I can talk to Scotland Yard. The police are still interested to know what happened to the gold from the Ballarat robbery. “
Turner ; “ No! you mustn’t talk to the police! I’m a respectable man now, I have a family here. It’s blackmail !! “
Turner doesn’t want to give in but he had no choice
Turner ; “ Alright, McCarthy. You win. You can live on the farm on my estate. But I don’t want to hear about Australia again. Never! “
Turner had no alternative about Charles living in Ross-On-Wye. But Charles keep blackmail Turner
Charles ; “ give me the money or the police are going to know everything about you Black Jack of Ballarat. Hahaha! “
Turner ; “ He even wanted his son to marry Alice to get my money. “
At Boscombe Pool, the day of the murder.
James ; “ I can’t marry Alice Turner, father, don’t ask me again ! “
Turner heard their conversation and felt very angry. He had no choice but to…
Charles ; “ Aaaarghh! Black Jack of Ballarat! “
Finally, this is the truth. After this case was closed, Holmes and Watsom returned home.
Seven months later. Holmes received news that John Turner is dead and Alice Turner and James was married. And John Turner’s secret was still a secret.